Macabre Musings Get The Boot

Macabre Musings Get The Boot
Could fiction be taken too seriously? Campuses try to prevent Virginia Tech violence. Should they be allowed on campus? Can college students emulate classics?
Steven Barber, a 23-year-old student at the University of Virginia at Wise, got expelled from school after submitting a piece of dark literature in his creative writing class. Was the administration justified? Probably not.
Promote this post on Yahoo! Buzz
Steven Barber, a 23-year-old student at the University of Virginia at Wise, got expelled from school after submitting a piece of dark literature in his creative writing class.

This is the story in summation, but it's not as linear as it seems. In Barber's fiction piece, the protagonist is on the verge of a mental break, which leads to murder and suicide. In Virgina, not long ago, the fictional subject matter covered in Barber's essay was all too real, when Seung-Hui Cho opened fired on his fellow students and took his own life in the same day.

Barber, fortunately, does not intend to kill his fellow University of Virginia students. Barber wants to continue and complete his undergraduate study, and that's it. Despite incriminating evidence pointing his way (after his professor set off an alarm to administrators, his property was searched and three guns were recovered), he was released from his mandatory psychological evaluation with a clean bill of mental health. 

The University of Virginia will not allow Barber back on campus.

As a 23-year-old, Barber is allowed to have guns on campus; all of them were acquired legally. In terms of his mental stability, Barber has not been proven to be a threat to others or himself. Unlike Cho, his last work of fiction was the only one that displayed dark subject matter.

So why can't he return to campus?

Edgar Allen Poe, who also called the University of Virginia home, would have been expelled under the same circumstances. Events like the Virginia Tech killings have heightened restrictions on creative license on campus, in other words students may have to shy away from musings reminiscent of Chuck Palahniuk.

Universities, including Boston University, University of New Mexico, and Virginia Tech, have published literature containing new policies to ensure safety on campus. Though the new standards may violate civil and privacy rights, these universities are still able to invade and restrict the lives of students, if there is "reasonable" evidence for doing so. 

Basically, your school can do whatever they want, if they deem you a "threat." In Barber's sad story, threat construction trumps all, he has been denied his appeal to resume his undergraduate study.     
Advertisement

Comments

Anonymous says,
Posted 05/26/2008 10:35 AM

Leave a comment

Please enter the text you see below or login to post with a username.

OTR MANAGING EDITORS

Hector Nazario
An Internet phenomenon in the manner of a Montauk Monster, except with 80% less Photoshop and 35% better looks.
Samantha Beerman
I'm a pop culture junkie with an alliteration obsession. My mission is to spread sarcasm and snark across the Web.
Tracy O'Neill
Fly like a butterfly; sting like a bee: harder faster stronger.
Related PostsPopular Editor's Picks

WHAT'S THE DEAL?

CollegeOTR is the country's premiere college blog, capturing the best of everything that happens at college. Post now to share!

FEATURED COLLEGES

RECENT COMMENTS

FRIEND AN EDITOR

Hector Nazario
Hector Nazario
Senior Managing Editor
Samantha Beerman
Samantha Beerman
Managing Editor: South
Tracy O'Neill
Tracy O'Neill
Managing Editor: West
Crystal Ames
Crystal Ames
The Fire Stopper